Mint Shutdown Alternative EU 2026 — Monarch, Rocket Money, Cleo, Fina Compared

Intuit pulled the plug on Mint on 23 March 2024, ending 17 years of free, ad-supported personal finance management for over 25 million users. The official migration suggestion was Credit Karma — a credit-monitoring product, not a budgeting app, and not available in most of Europe at all. The vacuum sucked four real contenders to the front: Monarch Money, Rocket Money (formerly Truebill), Cleo and Fina. None is a 1:1 Mint replacement. Each solves part of the problem. This is the EU 2026 side-by-side for choosing among them.

TL;DR

Direct verdict: Monarch Money is the closest spiritual successor to Mint — net worth, cashflow, household sharing, lots of charts. Rocket Money wins for bill-cancellation and subscription tracking. Cleo wins for younger users who want chat-style nudges. Fina wins for AI-driven categorisation and is the most flexible across regions, though bank coverage is the thinnest of the four.

Counter-case where each loses: Monarch costs ~95 EUR/year (Mint was free); Rocket Money locks core features behind a pay-what-you-want tier that nudges toward 12 USD/month; Cleo's "savings buddy" voice grates on power users; Fina is small and feature-incomplete in 2026.

EU + PL availability: All four are downloadable in the EU. PSD2 bank coverage in Poland is partial in all four. None denominates in PLN as primary currency.

Best for whom: Monarch for ex-Mint households. Rocket Money for subscription killers. Cleo for under-30s. Fina for early adopters of AI categorisation.

App features evolve. Test free tier first.

Quick Context — Why Mint Mattered and Why Its Loss Reshaped PFM

Mint was free. Mint synced 17,000+ US institutions and a respectable number of EU and UK banks. Mint had been the default answer to "which finance app should I use" for over a decade. Intuit bought it in 2009 for 170 million USD, then quietly let it stagnate while pouring product effort into TurboTax and QuickBooks. The 2023 sunset announcement was framed as a migration to Credit Karma; what it actually did was force 25 million users to choose between paid alternatives.

The casualties of this migration: European users got worse coverage (every replacement has thinner non-US bank lists), free-tier users got priced out, and the long tail of niche features (custom categories with rules, certain investment-tracking modes, specific export formats) all dropped. Polish users in particular lost the easiest entry path into PFM and got, in return, four apps that are mostly US-shaped.

In 2026, two years post-sunset, the dust has settled. Monarch absorbed the household budgeters. Rocket Money absorbed the subscription-conscious. Cleo absorbed the conversational-UI crowd. Fina is the wildcard.

Side-by-Side Comparison Table

Mint, by comparison: free, US data residency, English-only, all features at no cost, deprecated 2024.

Pricing Breakdown — What Each Costs in 2026 EUR

Monarch Money — 99 USD/year, ~13 EUR/month if billed monthly, ~8.30 EUR/month annual. No permanent free tier. Household sharing free. Currency-conversion fees on the order of 1-2 EUR/year for non-USD cardholders.

Rocket Money — pay-what-you-want from 4 USD/month to 12 USD/month, with the default nudge sitting at 6 USD/month. The premium features (subscription cancellation handling, smart savings, credit reporting) are gated behind the 10-12 USD tier. EU users pay USD; expect ~1 EUR FX overhead.

Cleo — Cleo Plus at 5.99 USD/month and Cleo Builder at 14.99 USD/month. The free tier covers chat-based budgeting nudges. Premium adds salary advance (US-only), credit building (US-only) and additional features. For European users the free tier is the realistic ceiling — most paid features don't apply.

Fina — variable subscription, currently around 60-80 EUR/year depending on region and promotion. Free 30-day trial. The cheapest of the four for what it offers — but also the youngest, with the smallest feature set.

Effective comparison: if you simply replace Mint's free utility with a paid subscription, expect 70-100 EUR/year in pure subscription cost. None of the four offers a permanent free tier comparable to Mint's. The age of free PFM ended in March 2024.

EU / PSD2 Specifics

None of the four holds its own AISP licence in every EU member state. They all rely on aggregators:

• Monarch uses Plaid Europe and Salt Edge. Broadest coverage of the four.
• Rocket Money uses Plaid primarily; EU coverage is the weakest because the product is heavily US-focused.
• Cleo uses TrueLayer (UK-centric) plus Plaid; strong UK coverage, decent EU, thin in Eastern Europe.
• Fina uses Salt Edge and Tink; better Nordic and Baltic coverage than the US-built three.

Data residency: Monarch and Rocket Money both store and process data in the US. Cleo splits data between UK and US infrastructure. Fina is the only one that can offer EU-region data residency on request — a real differentiator if you work in regulated industries or have strict employer policies.

Data export: Monarch and Rocket Money offer CSV. Cleo's export is more limited. Fina offers CSV plus JSON, and is the only one of the four that publishes a documented API (limited beta as of 2026).

Polish Reader Angle

Polish bank coverage 2026:

None denominates in PLN as primary currency. None tracks IKE, IKZE or Polish treasury bonds (obligacje skarbowe) at the wrapper level. None calculates Belka 19% capital-gains tax or the special 12% rate on PL treasury bonds. All four assume USD as base, with EUR/GBP/PLN as display layers — historical FX is not preserved, so a 3-year zł net-worth chart of EUR-denominated holdings will show false volatility.

For Polish users whose stack is PL banks + maybe one EU broker, the gap is real. Freenance is built EU-native, PL-bank first, with zł as a real base currency and Belka logic baked in. It will not replace Monarch for a US-bound ex-Mint user — but for a Polish reader looking for a Mint-shaped product that actually understands Polish banking and tax wrappers, an EU-built option is worth a serious look.

Migration Path — Coming Off Mint to Each App

If you exported your Mint CSV before 23 March 2024, all four accept the file format. Common pain points:

• Categories don't survive cleanly. Mint's category tree was idiosyncratic. Expect to spend 1-3 hours remapping.
• Custom rules never survive. You rebuild them in the new app.
• Investment cost basis is rarely transferred — you re-enter it.
• Bill detection has to relearn from a few months of fresh transactions.

If you didn't export in time, your history is gone. Most users in this bucket started from zero in 2024 and now have ~18-24 months of new history. That's enough for trend reporting in any of the four.

Per-app specifics:

• Monarch — direct Mint-CSV importer in the onboarding. Lowest friction.
• Rocket Money — accepts CSV but the import experience is rougher; many users skip history and start fresh.
• Cleo — limited history import; the product assumes you'll feed it via bank sync going forward.
• Fina — supports CSV + JSON import; the most flexible, but the smallest user community to help you troubleshoot.

Use Case Showdowns

Ex-Mint user who just wants the same dashboard

Winner: Monarch. It is the closest visual and functional analogue. The transition cost is one month's friction, then you're back to a Mint-like daily experience.

Subscription killer

Winner: Rocket Money. Its bill-negotiation and subscription-cancellation flows are unmatched. If your monthly spend is bleeding from 8 active streaming services, 3 forgotten gym memberships and a Photoshop subscription you don't use, the app pays for itself in month one.

Under-30s, wants a "friend" not a spreadsheet

Winner: Cleo. The chat-style interface, the savings nudges, the gamified streaks — they work for a specific demographic. Power users will hate it. Younger users will keep using it.

Investor with EU brokers

Winner: Monarch. Live valuations via Plaid Europe beat the other three. None handles EU tax wrappers natively.

Privacy-conscious, EU-data-residency required

Winner: Fina (closest). EU-region storage on request, JSON export, documented API. Still imperfect — not all aggregator hops stay in the EU — but the most aligned of the four.

Polish bank-first user

Winner: tie, none full fit. Monarch and Fina tie at "best of a bad bunch." For PL-native coverage, an EU-built tool is the cleaner choice.

Couple sharing finances

Winner: Monarch. Free household sharing. Rocket Money is single-user. Cleo is single-user. Fina has limited sharing.

What's Missing in All Four

• A permanent free tier comparable to Mint. None exists. The Mint business model — free, ad-supported, monetised via cross-sell to Intuit's other products — is gone.
• Native EU tax-wrapper logic. IKE, IKZE, PEA, ISA, TBSZ, Riester, BSPP are invisible to all four.
• Belka tax 19% / 12% calculation. All four show gross investment returns.
• True AI cashflow forecast. "Projected balance" lines exist; Monte Carlo on income volatility does not. The phrase "AI-powered" appears in all four marketing pages; in product, it usually means "rule-based categorisation with ML hints."
• OFX export. CSV only in three, CSV + JSON in Fina. Power users still leave for Firefly III or roll-their-own.
• Customer support outside English. Fina has token Nordic-language support; the others are English-only.
• Receipt OCR. Rudimentary in Monarch and Rocket Money; absent in the others.

Worked Example — Marek, 38, Engineer, Wrocław, Ex-Mint User

Marek used Mint for nine years. He banks at PKO BP (personal + joint with spouse), mBank (B2B side-project), Santander Polska (joint mortgage), holds a Trade Republic EUR account for ETF DCA and a small IKE-Obligacje. He tries all four for 30 days each (rolling).

Monarch (month 1). Imports his Mint CSV in 20 minutes. Connects PKO, mBank, Santander on first try; Trade Republic works via Plaid Europe (his spouse is impressed); IKE-Obligacje is a manual tracking account. By day 10 the household dashboard is mostly accurate. By day 30 he is paying ~8.30 EUR/month and considers it worth it.

Rocket Money (month 2). Marek skips the historical import and lets the app rebuild from live sync. It finds three subscriptions he had forgotten — saves him about 26 EUR/month immediately. But Santander Polska won't connect; mBank reconnects every 14 days; the budgeting layer is thinner than Monarch's. He keeps it open as a "subscription killer" and downgrades from premium after month one.

Cleo (month 3). The chat-based onboarding amuses him for two days, then irritates him. Bank coverage in Poland is poor; only mBank works. He uninstalls on day 18.

Fina (month 4). The AI categorisation is impressively accurate from day one. He likes that he can export to JSON. Bank coverage is the thinnest of the four — only mBank reconnects reliably. He keeps it as a side experiment but uses Monarch as primary.

Marek's final stack: Monarch as the household dashboard. Rocket Money on the free tier as a subscription scanner. A private spreadsheet for IKE-Obligacje and Belka tracking. Total annual cost: ~95 EUR for Monarch.

Friction points he logs: none of them denominate in PLN cleanly; none track Belka; none alert him before the 90-day SCA renewal forces him to re-OAuth each bank.

Verdict by User Type

FAQ

Can I get a free Mint replacement? Not really. Cleo and Rocket Money have free tiers, but the useful features (subscription cancellation, real budgeting) are paid. The age of fully-free PFM is over. Budget 60-100 EUR/year for any serious option.

Will I lose my historical Mint data if I migrate now (May 2026)? If you saved a CSV before 23 March 2024, you can still import it into any of the four. If you didn't, your data is permanently gone. Most users now have 18-24 months of fresh post-Mint history — enough for meaningful trends.

Which has the best customer support? Monarch has the most polished support (English, ~24h ticket turnaround). Rocket Money has chat support during US business hours. Cleo's support is informal. Fina is small enough that you sometimes get the founders.

Is Credit Karma a real Mint replacement? No. Credit Karma is a credit-monitoring product. It does not budget, does not categorise transactions in a useful way, does not work in most of the EU and was Intuit's lazy answer to the sunset question.

Can I use multiple replacement apps at once? Yes, and during your trials it makes sense. After trials end, doubling up on paid apps is wasteful unless you have a specific reason (e.g., Monarch for budgeting + Rocket Money free tier for subscriptions).

Does any of them work with IKE, IKZE or Polish bonds natively? No. All four treat them as opaque accounts. For tax-wrapper-native tracking you need a Polish or EU-built tool.

---

Sources (named, no URLs): Intuit Inc. (Mint sunset, 23 March 2024); Monarch Money, Inc.; Rocket Money (formerly Truebill, now part of Rocket Companies); Cleo AI Ltd. (UK); Fina (independent EU operator); Plaid Inc.; TrueLayer Ltd. (UK FCA-authorised AISP); Salt Edge Inc. (Canada/Estonia AISP); Tink AB (Sweden, Visa subsidiary); PSD2 directive (Directive (EU) 2015/2366); KNF (Polish Financial Supervision Authority).

App features evolve. Test free tier first.